Am I an elitist?

I just read an interesting column by Ben Shapiro on Townhall.com.  I'll tell you this:  I don't agree with everything that is written there.  If I did, I would probably belong to a cult.  And while I find Ben a good writer most days, I find this week's column a bit insulting. 

First of all, let's define the word "elitist," because it plays heavily in Ben's essay.

An elitist is someone who believes in rule by a special group of persons.   Elitism is the belief that certain persons or members of certain classes or groups deserve favored treatment by virtue of their perceived superiority, as in intellect, social status, or financial resources.

  • The sense of entitlement enjoyed by such a group or class.
  • Control, rule, or domination by such a group or class.

  • Personally, I would define it as out of touch with the mainstream.

    So am I an elitist?  Let's see.

    You’re an elitist if you love Brokeback Mountain, but think that John Wayne movies are jingoistic expressions of outdated American machismo.

    I saw Brokeback Mountain.  Hated every minute of it.  It wasn't because I'm somehow disturbed by the thought of two guys falling in love.  I could care less.  I was bored to tears with it.  There's only so much mountain scenery, livestock and dilapidated, dying towns I can look at in one movie without wanting to either vomit in my own mouth or fall asleep.  It was dull.  I find John Wayne movies boring too.  Maybe I'm just not a fan of westerns.

    You’re an elitist if you worry that Sarah Palin hunts moose, but aren’t worried that Barack Obama wants to meet personally with dictators.

    Not sure why the juxtaposition of the two.  I have no idea what hunting moose has to do with Hugo Chavez, but if it means stunning him with a Tazer, letting him loose in a jungle and hunting him down with poison dart arrows, I'm OK with it.  Does that make me an elitist?

    Personally, I think the above makes you ignorant about foreign policy, but elitist?  Not so much.

    You’re an elitist if you think Colin Powell was less “authentically black” than Barack Obama until Powell endorsed Obama.
    Elitist? Not so much. In my book that makes you racist, but not necessarily elitist.  "Authentic" skin color shouldn't be a criterion for choosing a president.  How many of you would shriek like impaled virgins if someone referred to John McCain as not "authentically white?"

    You’re an elitist if you quote the Book of Matthew to justify socialism, cite the Book of John to defend Bill Clinton, write off the Book of Romans as “obscure,” or deride the Old Testament as a collection of antiquated messages about shellfish and animal sacrifices.

    So if you're not a Biblical scholar or if you don't subscribe to Judeo-Christian beliefs, you're necessarily an elitist?  Or are you simply a hypocrite, if you write off certain portions of the Bible, while using others to justify hatred, theft and betrayal?

    You’re an elitist if you think that President Bush is stupid because he says “nucular,” while Joe Biden is a genius even though he thinks the word “jobs” has three letters.
    What if I think both are idiots?  Just curious.

    You’re an elitist if you think Joe the Plumber’s income and license status are more important than the question he asked Barack Obama.
    Actually, you're an elitist if you think Joe the Plumber's income and license status disqualify him from asking a legitimate question of a Presidential candidate.

    You’re an elitist if you think Bill Ayers is just a professor of English.
    No, you're an idiot.

    And speaking of bigots...

    You’re an elitist if you love watching soccer and you’re not a recent immigrant.

    Hello, Pot.  Let me introduce you to Kettle.  You both have something in common.

    You’re an elitist if you think George Clooney is a great artist.
    Having bad taste makes you an elitist?  I see.

    You’re an elitist if you think Sean Penn is a great diplomat.
    No, you're just a dolt.  I do, however, think Spicoli was a great role.

    You’re an elitist if you think Madonna is great at anything.
    She's great at self-promotion.  I must be an elitist!

    You’re an elitist if you worship John F. Kennedy.

    You’re an elitist if you’re excited at the prospect of government intervention in the banking system in the aftermath of the subprime meltdown.

    You’re an elitist if you think Nixon/Reagan/Bush was the nation’s worst president but Jimmy Carter is the nation’s best ex-president

    No, you're just historically and economically ignorant.  But elitist?  I. Think. Not.

    There is a slew of other criteria that compares and contrasts liberal and conservative philosophies, but you can see where I'm going with this.  Most of it is the definition of hypocrisy.  Some if it is just plain stupid.  What you eat, what you enjoy watching on the idiot box and what you read doesn't make you an elitist.  Your taste is your own, and not everyone who doesn't sit on the couch reading the Bible during their every free moment is an elitist.  If you're going to do satire, at least try to be funny.

     del.icio.us  Stumbleupon  Technorati  Digg 

     

    What did you think of this article?




    Trackbacks
    • No trackbacks exist for this entry.
    Comments

    • 10/21/2008 9:24 AM james wilson wrote:
      Stand-up would be good for him. The feedback is immediate, and humbling.
      Reply to this
    • 10/21/2008 11:28 AM NEO, SOC wrote:
      What sickens me most is the hypocrisy. For crying out loud IDIOTS pay attention to what you are saying! Wait! They won't do that because the purpose of the left speaking is to solely talk louder and hopefully drawn out the people who spent time to burn a couple of calories in their cerebral cortex.

      This country is doomed when talking points rules over common sense. The time is coming when we will be forced to fight and those who really love their country will die for an America that may never b restored again.
      Reply to this
    • 10/21/2008 11:29 AM NEO, SOC wrote:
      drawn should be drown

      sorry, I had a liberal moment! LOL!
      Reply to this
    • 10/21/2008 12:36 PM TerribleTroy wrote:
      Being very familar with the concept.. me thinks sanity has left the building. Between this thread (which I will call schmuko's) and the crazy racist beotch from shitcago.... I'm starting look saner by the day! I feel good ... and Im OUT of meds! The last time I felt this apprehensive for our Nation was 9/11 and the week that followed. Im teling you there is some Baaaaad shit getting ready to go down. Protect yourselves at all times...we're going in for a crash landing.

      Well Done Niki.. well done.. sure you dont want to road trip to IL this weekend? End of the world Rottfest.. would luv to meet you...
      Reply to this
      1. 10/21/2008 1:09 PM Nicki wrote:
        Troy, I'd give my left tit to go, but I have plans, not the least of which is a BBQ at my favorite SGM's house, and a jiu jitsu tournament for my son!  Drink some for me, OK?

        Does the DOG like this thread? 
        Reply to this
    • 10/21/2008 1:02 PM Vic wrote:
      Ben Shapiro used to be a decent columnist, but he's gotten to the point where he plays the "religious oppression" card the instant someone disagrees with him. IMHO, Shapiro is about as credible as somoene else who plays the "victim card" when someone disagrees with and/or criticizes him: Barack Obama.
      Reply to this
    • 10/21/2008 1:32 PM TerribleTroy wrote:
      DOG SAYS.. He luves everything you do darlin.... he is such a flirt!
      Reply to this
      1. 10/21/2008 1:46 PM Nicki wrote:
        Tell DOG he's always got a snuggle buddy! 
        Reply to this
    • 10/21/2008 6:32 PM straightarrow wrote:
      You may be an elitist if you think Shapiro's column warranted attention.

      Sorry, I just couldn't help it, I tried, really I did, but damn girl, you threw me a straight line.
      Reply to this
    Leave a comment

     Enter the above security code (required)

     Name (required)

     Email (will not be published) (required)

     Website

    Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.